Sunday, September 30, 2012

What is Right and What is Easy: Cedric Diggory and the Passover




            In the fourth book of the Harry Potter series, Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, the storyline begins to take a darker turn. The evil wizard, Voldemort, returns from being almost-but-not-quite-dead and the first thing he does is murder a boy-wizard named Cedric Diggory. As Goblet of Fire ends, Dumbledore—if you are unfamiliar with the books, Dumbledore is the headmaster at the wizarding school, Hogwarts—eulogizes Cedric before the student body with these words, "Remember Cedric. Remember, if the time should come when you have to make a choice between what is right and what is easy, remember what happened to a boy who was good, and kind, and brave, because he strayed across the path of Lord Voldemort. Remember Cedric Diggory."
            The Passover is to the Israelites what Cedric Diggory would be for the wizarding world—minus the flying broomsticks and butterbeer. The Passover, and accompanying Feast of Unleavened Bread, is about remembering the oppression and cruelty of the past in order to keep from repeating them in the future. It is a tradition that originates out of the Israelites’ slavery in Egypt and the killing of the firstborn that finally led to their exodus. These festivals were instituted by God to remember the cruelty of slavery so that it may not be repeated, but they also serve a secondary purpose: they are an antidote for nostalgia.[1] Those of you who know the story of the exodus well may remember how quickly the Israelites are in need of this antidote. They can practically still see the Red Sea—the site of the miraculous parting of the waters—many of them still have the lashes of the slave-drivers, persecuted by a Pharaoh who did not know Joseph and was therefore unaware of their history, and still those Israelites quickly turn on Moses and wish to go back to the land of Egypt—site of the good ol’ days. Nostalgia, even for times that were not good by any measure, is a uniquely human response to adversity. When difficulty comes, the Israelites need to be reminded again and again that they are fleeing from a broken past and the journey—no matter its challenges—is worth it. The Passover bids them to remember the past in order to set their course for the future.
            The Israelites’ situation is not that different from the one facing the wizarding world when Voldemort returns, or, for that matter, our world today. We need something to rally behind in order to keep from wishing away our lives forever gazing into what has been. Why did the wizarding world need to remember Cedric Diggory? Because they were about to be plunged into internal conflict under questioned leadership. Why did the Israelites need a festival to remember the Passover? Because they were about to be plunged into internal conflict under questioned leadership. Where are we today? In constant internal conflict under questioned political, economic, social, and religious leadership.
            The world turns, but things—whether in the wilderness, at Hogwarts or in Kittson County—hardly change; we face the same challenges and tough choices. We are in need of an antidote for nostalgia. There is much that is wrong with the world today and also much that we are indebted to the past, but we make a terrible mistake when we get our destiny backwards. God’s future for us is just that—in our future, ahead of us. History does not move backwards toward the Garden of Eden. We are always moving forward, like Israel, into a future promised to us, and again—like Israel—our entrance into it will be kicking and screaming and dragging our feet. We want to go back. God pushes us forward.
That is why we must remember. Remember the Passover. Remember the times when we have been persecuted and remember when we have been the persecutors. Remember human beings at their worst—Darfur and Auschwitz, the Gulags, apartheid, slavery, the Inquisition, the Third Reich; it goes on and on. Remember all our Cedric Diggorys. I’m not just talking about issues bigger than what we can control. We need to process together all the mistakes we have made; we need to be unafraid of what we may discover if we go deeper.
What we will inevitably find is that at our base we are all like the Israelites, eager to return to what is comfortable in our past. Left on our own we will do things how we’ve done them before; if it’s not broke, don’t fix it. Even if it is broke, pretend like it isn’t and do it just the same. We will reach back for a past as beautiful and shiny as it is unrealistic and untrue. At our base this is who we are, but in no small part because of the God who leads us forward we are also much more than this. God re-orients us—God reminds us—where our true destiny lies.
At its core that is what festivals are about: remembering something important from our past and remembering who we are; not so that we can repeat that past but so that we can live into the future. Festivals tell us something true about the past in order to tell us something true about the present, and in-so-doing they tell us that the most important moment for the history of the faith is always right now. It’s the only moment that includes all other moments, learns from all moments, and bridges where we have been to where we are going. Festivals are a bridge from the past to the future on which we stand right now with a choice before us—forward or backward; what is right or what is easy.
Remember Cedric Diggory, Dumbledore said, because the time will come when you have to make a choice between what is right and what is easy. Easy, comfortable—words for a time when there is nothing on the line—but the truth is that there is always something on the line. The Israelites teach us that God’s people are not just a generation away from extinction but only a moment away from turning back to the path that is easy. We live in such a world of luxury that we actually value things that are easy. Somehow the good life has been equated with comfortability. The Passover tears that comfort apart.
We are not our own, have never been our own, will never be our own. We are part of a web that stretches back to those Israelites and forward to the advent of the Kingdom of God in which no moment in time matters as much as here and now. We walk alongside the Israelites in the wilderness; we walk alongside all those hurt and broken; we stand for what we believe because of the God who works in and through us today and the God who worked in and through our ancestors before us. There is no separating the past and the present, just as there is no reliving what has happened before. The past is always behind us, reminding us of where we’ve been and tempting us to return, but the Promised Land lies ahead. Remember Cedric Diggory; remember the captivity in Egypt; remember the hurt you carry with you; then, allow that hurt to be the catalyst that pushes you forward.
It won’t be easy. That’s a promise. We have a choice—every day of our lives—between what is right and what is easy. Cedric Diggory bids us to choose well. So does the Passover.
Amen.


[1] Katheryn Schifferdecker, WorkingPreacher podcast

No comments:

Post a Comment