Friday, April 29, 2011

Vanity of Vanities: A Sermon on WikiLeaks and Ecclesiastes

Ecclesiastes 1:12-18
I, the Teacher,* when king over Israel in Jerusalem, applied my mind to seek and to search out by wisdom all that is done under heaven; it is an unhappy business that God has given to human beings to be busy with. I saw all the deeds that are done under the sun; and see, all is vanity and a chasing after wind.*
What is crooked cannot be made straight,
   and what is lacking cannot be counted.

I said to myself, ‘I have acquired great wisdom, surpassing all who were over Jerusalem before me; and my mind has had great experience of wisdom and knowledge.’ And I applied my mind to know wisdom and to know madness and folly. I perceived that this also is but a chasing after wind.*
For in much wisdom is much vexation,
and those who increase knowledge increase sorrow.



NOTE: This sermon is written for Preaching and Pop Culture, an independent study I designed with Chris Scharen. The topic for this third of three sermons is "WikiLeaks and Open information"

Sermon

Sir Francis Bacon is credited with a famous quote that goes like this: “Knowledge is power.” This innocuous phrase has become a sort of motto for the 21st century. Who could disagree that the more we know about life the better it becomes? For modern people, the purpose of life seems to be two-fold: part one is to accumulate as much wealth as possible, and part two is to glean an equally impressive array of knowledge. In our formal schooling we are tested on knowledge often with standardized information and textbook regurgitation. We are taught by the scientific method and how to debate rationally. The importance of test scores is stressed from the time we learn the alphabet. Success comes to those who prove their knowledge. Those who are able to give the desired answers will get better paying jobs.
All of this occurs for a very good reason in principal. It is good to learn. It is good to read books and learn skills, to gather information and to put it into practice in tangible ways. The proper way to assemble a combustion engine is important as are the rules of punctuation. Yet, this rather self-evident view on the importance of knowledge rams up against today’s reading from Ecclesiastes. If we are honest about the implications, this reading should probably leave us at least a little troubled. It brings up awkward questions. What if this knowledge we have gained doesn’t actually get us anywhere? What if knowledge isn’t actually power but an illusion? To say that knowledge and wisdom are mere chasing after the wind seems a short step away from nihilism.
Ecclesiastes has a very counterintuitive message for we who live in the 21st century. We live in a WikiLeaks world. With a basic knowledge of the internet and a bit of curiosity everything is at our fingertips. Thirty years ago if you had a question about a famous quotation or a baseball player’s statistics you would need to pore over a library catalogue of many out-of-date reference sources. Today, you can Google an answer in seconds from your computer, your phone or countless other digital, electronic devices that are being developed at a dizzying rate. If knowledge is power, we are a pretty powerful people. Daily newspapers have given way to radios and televisions, which have given way to computers and smart phones, and the future guarantees only more and faster means of accessing the information that we all crave. Knowledge is a rushing river always flowing past us; it is easy these days to feel as if we are swept away.
This is precisely where Ecclesiastes has some surprisingly wisdom. The reality is that we have this knowledge as a tool, not as a life jacket; it can help us but it does not save us. When knowledge is sought as a means of power it is only vanity, but as a tool for the work that God put us on the earth to do it is necessary and good. The author of Ecclesiastes, who calls him or herself Qoholeth, writes, “For in much wisdom is much vexation, and those who increase knowledge increase sorrow.” The message is simple and clear: the more you learn, the more complicated the world becomes. Things no longer look black-and-white; instead everything begins to look many shades of gray. This can be frightening, and yet it can help us to see those who we previously ignored.
Knowledge is one of those strangely wonderful things in life that only matters when it is shared. To horde information benefits nobody. This is the founding principle of an organization like WikiLeaks, which seeks to make secret government documents public on the web. The fact that knowledge is power is evident in the mixed but strong reception that WikiLeaks has received. Opinions have been decidedly vehement on both sides of the issue. Whether you agree or disagree with the idea of complete and open information you cannot deny that the audience is captivated by it. We always want to know what’s going on! On some level, we are still children who keep asking the question, “Why?” though good manners have long taught us it is most proper to stay quiet.
Questions drive us. We ask trivial things like, “Where do you want to eat?” or “What shirt matches these shorts?” And we ask deeply meaningful questions like, “Will you marry me?” or “Would you like to be marked as do not resuscitate?” The questions matter; the answers matter. But what matters more, if Ecclesiastes teaches us only one thing, is that knowledge is not an end to itself. You can learn and learn and learn, but all will be chasing after the wind. Yet, when that knowledge is shared it becomes a gift of unimaginable power.
This is the life of faith in a nutshell. To know Jesus Christ means that we feel the overwhelming need to share that faith with the world. We don’t hold it secret, as if to horde Christ’s power, but we make it known through the gospel. That is what knowledge is about. Nothing is new under the sun, writes Qoholeth. What is new and enlightening is the message of Jesus Christ, given for you. That is life-changing information; it is knowledge finally greater than a mere tool. It is the knowledge of salvation that overcomes the vanity of vanities, and gives us the freedom to find meaning in whatever earthly knowledge we accumulate in the time being.
So, when you feel like you are chasing after the wind you do not need to find meaning in a WikiLeaks document. You don’t need to spend your life poring over library books, Google searches or Facebook posts. Knowledge on its own is the vanity of vanities, but through Christ we are given knowledge of a different kind, knowledge of salvation that frees us to love and serve God and not our own self-serving need to know. So, go forth in the knowledge that you have been saved by Christ, who has risen from the tomb, and that is all you need to know.
Amen.

Wednesday, April 27, 2011

The Us-Them Problem, part 1...

This post has been a long time coming, but I finally feel the need after my discovery yesterday of the website called "White Whine". This site has picked up the now normal internet tradition of mocking a group of people, perhaps seen most famously in "People of Walmart."  At its best, "White Whine" is funny; at its worst it is depressing. You can say the same about People of Walmart.


Neither, however, offers any alternative. It's one thing to openly mock a group of people--and believe me, I know how much there is to mock about the entitled, middle-upper class white culture in America--but there needs to be some upshot to it, or you know what--people will react how they do to guilt.  They'll become more guilty or more angered. It's law without gospel.

This is the problem I have with racism workshops that tell us that we are racist by default if we are white in America, because we are born into a society saturated by systemic racism. OK, fair enough. But what does that actually tell us about who we are as people of God? We are all sinful. White and black have all fallen short of the glory of God. We oppress each other by our very nature.

To say that white people have power and therefore they are racist strikes me as an argumentum ad lazarum (appeal to poverty). It is a radical shift attempting to restore balance by tearing into the dominant culture. It may in fact be an accurate summation of the situation, but I also find it less than helpful.

Here's a rather pointed problem: Was Jesus racist? He was born into a Jewish culture that had power over the half-Jewish Samaritans. If we're going to claim that Jesus wasn't racist over the Samaritans because it strikes us as blasphemy than maybe we should stop throwing these words around and start searching for an alternative.

So, what do we do about sites like these? What do we do about systemic racism, feminism, sexism and the like? We change the framework for the discussion. We do this not by pointing out that white people are racist for reasons outside of their control or that white people whine about a lot of trivial things. Instead, we preach the story of the rich man as gospel. Rich football players are in financial straits because of high-risk loans because money and power simply do not give meaning. You can spend and spend, or save and save and all that will come of it are more complications. Money is the root of all evil--not just for those who have no money but primarily for those who do have it!

So we have this profound freedom to let ourselves go. Don't whine. Don't hoard. Don't cheat others and yourself to advance yourself in a broken society. Why? Because you will find well-being (which is to say, salvation) in this freedom. Without the good news I fear that their message will always be just another structure ignored by those who have found more advantageous grounds.

You are part of a situation that goes before you and will go on after you. You have created boundaries for your own self-preservation that have hindered those who need you most. You have sinned against your neighbor in thought, word and deed by what you have done and by what you have left undone. You have not loved the Lord, your God.

This is most certainly true. But it is not the end. The world needs gospel.

So here it is: Now, you are forgiven. In fact, you are liberated. You don't have to play by the rules any longer. You don't need to be a feminist to love a woman. You don't need to defeat racism to see beyond colors. You don't need to be gay to love somebody who is gay, bisexual, or straight. Your salvation is certain. Now go act like it.

I intend to follow up on this discussion sometime in the coming weeks with a different approach, and--I hope--a more well-rounded argument.

Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Drenched

Every year it seems to be the same old stories. Floods here, floods there. If it's not the Red River Valley (though seriously, when is it not the Red River Valley?), it's the Ohio River or Mississippi or the Missouri. It's the Gulf Coast, tsunamis and spills. It's the Glades, it's Pacific islands, it's...

Water is life. And death. We're made up mostly of it. We're drenched in it.

Every religious tradition has its flood story. Every tradition that I know of has water as a symbol near its heart. And this is no doubt because of water's ubiquity. When I look outside today I feel wet. The rainfall may only be a drizzle, but it pierces the skin. It is both a physical need and a powerful metaphor. The uncertainty of the future looms like storm clouds. You might say it's like sitting under a dunk tank. Water is life; it is also death.

When we talk about resurrection, especially in the Easter season, we tend to use the symbol of the open tomb, but I tend to prefer the image of the risen Christ on the shoreline cooking fish for his disciples (John 21). Fish live in the water. Fish breathe through the water. They don't escape it but embrace it. They are at home there. And so are we.

I got some flack for calling the Pacific Northwest "The Drear" in my post last week. So, today I switched it to the "Salmon Lands," but it comes to nearly the same thing. When we look up into the murky, gray sky we tend to feel lost. The clouds, however, bring much more than despair. That murk is bringing with it new life. April showers don't just bring May flowers; they resurrect life from death. Our hope lies in being drenched.

Luther reminds us that we are put to death in baptism and raised as a new creation. To be a new creation is to be a fish. It means to swim in the waters without fear because Christ surrounds us. Christ is, in fact, the very living water in which we move and breathe, and that which we drink in. The waters of destruction only fill in our milieu; they can do not more than turn us about. Pollution may seep into our lives and put our bodies to death, but we are promised that through it all we are drenched. The water is the very environs of our lives.

So rather than the simple "Remember your baptism" that many of us church-goers hear in worship. Let me offer you a stronger alternative. You are a fish. The waters will not get you. And that's good because you are drenched.

Hiking Thoughts for a Dreary Day


Yesterday, I picked up some hiking guides for the Superior Hiking Trail. Having semi-extensively checked out the BWCA hiking trails in the last few summers I decided it's time to move on to the more well-traveled SHT. Already, I have at least one planned trip and probably more (assuming I don't get a call right away).

So, here's my reason for this: I'm really looking for anybody who might want to come along on a trip this summer. I already have the makings of an easier trip in the works, but I'm also looking for a partner or two for a legitimate hike with some elevation change--nothing huge, just something fun for a few days.

Let me know if you have any interest!

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

Geographical Regions of America

This post is a direct response to Kate's insistence that Ohio is part of the Midwest. Basically, I have found this frequently: people from a place refer to their home region with a term that doesn't make sense. Ohio in the mid-west, really?

OK, this isn't just a rant against Ohio. In fact, I think a lot of regions of the U.S. are mistakenly named. The best regional name includes features of a landscape that are similar and remains something that people can describe. So, as much I may think of Ohio, Kentucky and parts of Indiana as the Ohio River Valley region that doesn't really work either. I doubt a person from Toledo is going to say, "Yeah, I'm Ohio River Valleyan" in the way they'd say "I'm Midwestern."

Also, I want to stay away from terms used negatively about an area. Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania is not, to me, part of the Rust Belt anymore than Utah is part of the Mormon belt. It strikes me suddenly that maybe Ohio's problem is that they can lay claim to too many things.

But anyway, on to the business at hand. For the sake of simplicity, no state is broken up into parts, though clearly many have varying geographical and self-identifying features. This is for ease of description. The following is a list, by geographical region, of the new names for U.S. Regions:

Salmon Lands: Alaska, Washington, and Oregon
Big Sun: Hawaii, California
Desert-land: Nevada, Arizona and New Mexico
The Peaks: Idaho, Montana, Colorado, Utah, Wyoming
Amber Waves of Grain: North Dakota, South Dakota, Nebraska, Kansas, Oklahoma, Iowa, Illinois
Many Lakes: Minnesota and Wisconsin
Hoosier Lands: Indiana
Ozark Country: Missouri, Arkansas
The Cumberland: Kentucky, Tennessee
Coal Zone: Pennsylvania, West Virginia
Millions of Peaches: Georgia
Hurricania: Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, Alabama, Florida, South Carolina
Colonial Land: North Carolina, Virginia, Maryland, Delaware
Great Lakes: Michigan, Ohio
Heart of the Hudson: New York, New Jersey
The Ivies: Connecticut, Rhode Island, Massachusetts
Bed-and-Breakfast Land: New Hampshire, Vermont
The Big Lobster: Maine

Tuesday, April 19, 2011

21st Century Prohibition: Online Poker

Last Friday the FBI shut down several of the biggest online poker sites (at least in the United States) and indicted several of their financial backers. Moreover, the future of the US Chess League (sponsored largely by Pokerstars) is now in serious question as well.
I have a couple of friends who are professional poker players and several more who play frequently and indeed subsidize their income through poker, so I feel the need to make a couple of comments. Firstly, I have an uneasy relationship with professional poker--or any kind of gambling. My problem is that you aren't actually contributing anything to society as a poker pro--there is no end product. Essentially money is trading hands in perpetuity with the more skillful--or immediately lucky--making money off of the less-skilled (why the U.S. capitalist economy hasn't embraced--legalized and taxed--this is beyond me!).

And yet, all the players are willing and there is certainly a good deal of skill and work involved. It does seem a little funny, at the very least, that the government is cracking down on poker financiers at a time when mortgage financiers on Wall Street have taken advantage of others who did not choose to willingly participate in what was essentially a gambling enterprise. So, this strikes me as very similar to prohibition in a 21st century context. There are undoubtedly going to be a lot of lawsuits, and my only prediction is that this is going to get messier before it gets clearer.

Of course, our game in Bockman Hall is still on :-)

Friday, April 15, 2011

Warning: Chess-related content

I haven't posted much chess-related content lately. I've kind of been focused on, you know, graduating and stuff. But I am heading down south (well, as much as one can say that Iowa is south) to play in Okoboji this weekend, and I'm really looking forward to setting aside school and the call process and all that to focus on something different for a couple days.

Here's a recent blitz game I played on ICC that shows I at least have some occasional skills...


Play online chess




I might post a recap come next week. I guess we'll see!